We were at the end of our Virgin Media contract last month. There are things I do not like about Virgin, but the package we're on isn't normally expensive, includes Eurosport so I can watch cycling, and if the broadband speed went above 100MB, I'd need to get some new hardware and in practice, any broadband delays aren't down to the speed at this end.
Amongst the things I do not like are that they a) hike up the price considerably when you're at the end of your deal and b) chop it down again without arguing when you ring to say that you're considering leaving as a result. I get that it's a tax on not being able to do those calls, but it would save everyone if they just stopped messing around.
After that was sorted out, the Virgin person working from home (and doing some tumble drying in the background!) went 'Oh, you've got a TiVo and the old Superhub modem, we'll give you the new TV box and the Media Hub 3. For free.'
That sounded fine but...
It turns out that the new TV box may store more recordings (I tend to have a full disk most of the time) but it's more of a pain to use. Unless I am missing something, there's no simple way to say 'just show me what's on this channel from now'. Instead, it would like you to compare seven or eight channels now and for the next hour or two.
Sometimes, that is what you want (and the Tivo would let you compare channels now) but, here at least, I want to know what's coming up on, say, Sky Documentaries for the next day or two.
I am guessing that it's not a total coincidence that several channels more are now HD only (and so take up more disk space if you record from them) than before. The TiVo had Film 4 in SD as well as HD and, for me, SD is OK if it means I can have twice as much. (Similarly, I don't have a Blu-ray player: I can buy far more second-hand DVDs for the money that even second-hand Blu-rays cost.)
OK, I may get used to some of this, how's the modem?
The Superhub was distinctly 'meh' as a router. So for the past ages, I have just used it as a modem and had a better third party bit of kit to do the router bits. Actually, I must have started doing this even before moving here in 2011 and getting Virgin* By the end of the time in London, it was a Linksys WRT54GS, flashed with third party firmware to enable me to do all sorts of interesting things..
.. like go 'my internet connection is more important than L16's, so if necessary, limit his speed, not mine'. Ahem.
That router turned out to be not fast enough to cope with Virgin's speeds even at the 50MB I think we were originally on - if I looked at the bandwidth graph, it would work fine for say thirty seconds, then have a lie down for ten, repeat - so I started using Mikrotik's excellent routers. They're not exactly user-friendly, but they are both cheap and good.
So the I had everything happily set up here: each bit of kit had its own fixed IP address so that various programs could talk to each other easily. The moOde music player in the kitchen is at 192.168.88.22 - so the control app on the phone can talk to it - and gets most of its music from 192.168.88.59 etc etc etc.
OK, the Hub 3 is supposed to be better, let's set up the IP addresses on it. And you can, painfully, sort of. None of this being shown what's connected by name, you have to know the MAC address of its network ports. Then what IP address you can set it to is limited and changing it from 192.168.0.x to 192.168.88.x causes another problem. (At least the Hub 3 lets you do that: looking, the Hub 4 doesn't let you move off 192.168.0.x?!)
It's also not keen on reassigning IP addresses while something is connected either, so I was doing a lot of plugging in, checking if it worked this time, unplugging when it didn't, changing the settings, repeat.
Towards the start of this, I had plugged the Mikrotik router into the PC in bedroom two so I could get the MAC addresses off its tables. (I didn't need to know them on it, but it would show them to me all together in a way that the Hub 3 wouldn't.)
It didn't take long to come to the conclusion that the solution was to just keep using the Mikrotik for nearly everything. I could switch the Hub 3 into 'modem' mode, where it doesn't do any of the networking stuff, just provides a connection to the outside internet, but it looks like even that's not as sensible as it could be and I'd already gone through the 'it could be easier, couldn't it, Google?' process of changing what the Chromecast is connected to.
So at the moment, the Mikrotik is connected to the Hub 3 acting as router, along with the TV box and the Chromecast. I get to keep the old network setup for the various other bits of kit and it seems to work..
.. but it's not exactly an improvement.
* In London, L had one of the original cable companies - Telewest? - provide her phone in New Cross in the late 1980s. When she moved to Crofton Park around 1994, she expected to use them again.. except it turned out that when they did cabled the main road a few hundred metres away they didn't do the road parallel to it that she bought the house on. When they merged with someone and ended up being taken over by Virgin, no-one else wanted to do the expensive bit of laying the cables either, so we were stuck with copper broadband until BT - years after they said they would do so - did 'fibre to the cabinet' there. By that point, we'd moved.